Student Life

How to Pick a College Essay Topic: The Do's and Don'ts

Show admissions officers why you are a perfect fit for their college.

Student Contributor, Shagun Srivastava

September 18, 2024

How to Pick a College Essay Topic: The Do's and Don'ts
Make sure your college essay will do it's job: capture the attention of the admissions committee.
Choosing the perfect topic can make or break your college essay. Discover critical strategies to choose a compelling and authentic topic that genuinely reflects who you are.

How to Pick a College Essay Topic

Choose a Topic That Reflects Your True Self

Your college essay should be a reflection of your genuine self. Pick a topic that reveals your core values, passions, and personality traits.
Reflect on experiences or moments that have profoundly shaped your identity. Whether it’s overcoming a personal challenge, pursuing a unique interest, or achieving a significant milestone, ensure the topic you choose resonates with who you are at your core. For example, if you’ve been deeply involved in a hobby such as music, art, or sports, consider writing about how this passion has influenced your life. Explain how it has shaped your perspective, work ethic, or interpersonal relationships.
Admissions officers are looking for a glimpse into your authentic self, so choosing a topic that allows you to showcase your individuality is vital.

Focus on Specificity

Broad or generic topics often need to capture the reader's attention. Instead, focus on a specific experience or moment that has had a meaningful impact on you. Specificity allows you to provide detailed insights and demonstrates your unique perspective.
For instance, concentrate on a particular project or event where you made a notable difference rather than writing about general volunteer work. Describe the context, your role, and the outcomes. Specific details make your essay more engaging and help the admissions committee understand the significance of your experience and its impact on your personal growth.

Show, Don’t Just Tell

A compelling essay goes beyond mere description. Use vivid imagery and anecdotes to bring your topic to life. Instead of simply stating that you faced a challenge, show how it affected you emotionally and intellectually. Describe the steps you took to overcome it and the lessons you learned. For example, if you’re writing about a challenging situation, such as overcoming a fear or tackling a difficult project, illustrate the experience with rich details. Describe your feelings, thoughts, and actions in a way that allows readers to visualize and empathize with your journey. This approach makes your essay more engaging and helps convey the depth of your experiences.

Reflect on Your Growth

Admissions officers are interested in understanding your personal development. Choose a topic that highlights how you have evolved as a person. Reflect on moments of challenge, learning, or transformation, and explain how these experiences have contributed to your growth. For example, if you’ve faced a significant obstacle, discuss the challenge itself and how it helped you develop resilience, adaptability, or other valuable qualities. Reflect on the skills and insights you gained and how they have prepared you for future challenges. This reflection demonstrates your ability to learn from experiences and grow as an individual.

Consider Your Audience

While choosing a topic, keep in mind the audience who will be reading your essay. Admissions officers are looking for genuine, heartfelt narratives that offer insight into your character. Select a topic you feel comfortable discussing openly, reflecting your true self. Consider what aspects of your story will resonate with the admissions committee and how you can present them authentically and engagingly. Avoid topics that you think might impress others but don’t truly reflect your experiences or perspectives. Authenticity is crucial for making a lasting impression.

How NOT to Pick a College Essay Topic

Avoid Clichés and Overused Topics

Clichéd topics can make your essay blend in with others. Avoid common themes such as generic sports victories or mission trips unless you can provide a unique angle. Choose a topic that stands out and offers a fresh perspective. For example, if writing about a sports experience, focus on a specific moment or lesson learned rather than a general victory. Highlight what made this experience unique to you. You ensure your essay is memorable and distinctive by offering a new take on familiar themes.

Don’t Be Overly Ambitious

While ambition is a positive trait, don’t choose a topic that feels too grand or abstract. Avoid topics that may seem unrealistic or disconnected from your personal experiences. Instead, focus on topics that allow you to discuss your genuine experiences and insights. For example, writing about solving global issues might come across as insincere if not presented thoughtfully. Choose a topic you can discuss in-depth, providing concrete examples and reflections. This approach ensures that your essay is both authentic and impactful.

Avoid Negative or Controversial Topics

Be cautious with negative or controversial subjects. Topics that delve into personal hardships or contentious issues can be challenging to present effectively without seeming like a pity plea or a rant. Instead, focus on topics that allow you to highlight your strengths and positive attributes. For instance, if discussing a personal challenge, frame it in a way that emphasizes your growth and resilience rather than dwelling on negative aspects. This approach helps you present yourself positively while acknowledging your ability to overcome difficulties.

Don’t Rely on External Sources

Your essay should be a reflection of your own experiences and thoughts. Avoid relying heavily on quotes, stories, or ideas from others. Admissions officers want to hear your voice and perspective, not a regurgitation of external ideas. If you’re using a metaphor, make sure you commit to it throughout the essay, not just at the beginning or end. Instead, focus on crafting an essay that showcases your unique perspective and personal experiences. You ensure your essay is authentic and engaging by sharing your insights and reflections. This approach helps you present a genuine account of who you are and what you bring to the table.

Finding the Right Topic

In conclusion, selecting the right college essay topic involves introspection, specificity, and authenticity. By focusing on what truly matters to you and avoiding common pitfalls, you can craft a compelling and memorable essay that stands out in the admissions process. Remember, the best topics reflect who you are and what you bring. By following these do’s and don’ts, you’ll be well on your way to choosing an essay topic that showcases your individuality and sets you apart from the competition. Take the time to reflect on your experiences and choose a topic that allows you to present your true self in the best possible light. A well-chosen topic, authentic and detailed, can make all the difference in your college application.

You Might Also Like

Join Fastweb.
Match Instantly.

Become a member and gain exclusive access to our database of over 1.5 million scholarships.

I am a:
Parents: Complete the questions using your child's information
Please select a grade level
Please enter a valid zip code.

By clicking, I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.