What are the Downsides to Using Home Equity to Refinance Student Loan Debt?
Home equity and student loan payments.
October 22, 2012
I have almost $200K in student loan debt at interest rates from 6.5% to 8.5%. My parents are offering to take on $70K of my debt that’s at 8.5% by way of a mortgage they have access to at 3.5%, provided that I am able to pay it off in 3 years. Given my current job situation, I can handle the monthly payment to them ($2K) in addition to the monthly payment for my remaining loans ($1,100 a month over 10 years) without any major problems. The plan is, once I’ve paid off the first $70K loan from them, the remaining amount would be cycled into their loan. This sounds like a no-brainer for me, given my amazingly supportive parents. Are there any downsides to paying off loans like this? — S.R.
Substituting a 3.5% rate loan for an 8.5% rate loan will save a significant amount of money. Refinancing $70,000 in student loan debt that is currently at 8.5% with a 3.5% interest rate will save about $160 per month and about $5,700 over the 3-year term of the loan. Using a 3-year term saves an additional $24,600 as compared with a 10 year term.
There are, however, a few risks associated with such a refinance.
Federal education loans have fixed interest rates. Mortages, home equity loans and home equity lines of credit may have either fixed interest rates or variable interest rates. If the 3.5% rate loan has a variable interest rate, that rate could rise, increasing the cost of the debt. It is reasonable to assume that variable rates will rise during the economic recovery by about the same amount as they fell at the start of the economic downturn, by about 5 to 6 percentage points.
However, the Federal Reserve has indicated that it will continue to suppress interest rate increases through 2015. So long as the variable rate debt is paid off in full within the next three years, the interest rate is unlikely to increase by much.
The main risk is that the borrower will not be able to pay off the $70,000 loan in three years. Refinancing the student loan debt into a 3-year term increases the monthly payment by almost $1,200. A salary reduction or job loss might make it more difficult for the borrower to afford the higher loan payments. This could stretch the parent’s debt into a longer term loan, increasing the likelihood of an interest rate increase. This could ultimately cost more than keeping the loan at a higher fixed rate.
Even if the borrower successfully repays the $70,000 loan in 3 years, he shouldn’t count on being able to continue at a 3.5% interest rate for much longer than that.
Note also that federal student loans offer several options for financial relief that are not available to mortgage borrowers. For example, unemployed borrowers can get the economic hardship deferment for up to three years. The federal student loans also offer income-based repayment and public service loan forgiveness.
There’s also the risk of default. If a borrower defaults on a mortgage, he can lose the home. If a borrower defaults on a federal student loan, the government cannot repossess his education. However, the government has very strong powers to compel repayment, such as garnishing up to 15% of wages and Social security benefit payments, offsetting federal and state income tax refunds, and blocking renewal of professional licenses.
A less risky option is to accelerate repayment of the 8.5% fixed rate loans by making extra payments to principal every month. The shorter repayment term accounts for about four-fifths of the savings from refinancing to a lower rate on a 3-year term, with the remaining fifth due to the lower interest rate. When making an extra payment to principal, send a letter to the lender asking for the extra money to be applied to the principal balance of the highest interest rate loan.
Borrowers of student loans and mortgages can deduct the interest on their debts, but there are some differences. The student loan interest deduction allows borrowers to deduct up to $2,500 in federal and private student loan interest as an above-the-line exclusion from income. Borrowers can claim this deduction even if they don’t itemize. Taxpayers can deduct interest on up to $100,000 in home equity debt borrowed for purposes other than home improvement, if they itemize. This deduction may be reduced or eliminated by the alternative minimum tax (AMT). Given that the interest on the remaining $130,000 in student loan debt exceeds the $2,500 threshold, allowing the parents to claim a deduction on $70,000 in home equity debt may yield additional savings.
The parents should, however, consult with a tax preparer. The parents may be required to treat the interest portion of the payments they receive from the student as income. It’s not a significant amount of income, about $1,300 a year, but it will offset the savings from the home equity interest deduction. The parents should also consider memorializing the arrangement with a formal promissory note.
The possible passage of future legislation is not enough reason to skip an opportunity for significant savings. A 5 percentage point reduction in the interest rate is worthwhile, provided that the student is certain that he will be able to repay the debt within the 3 year term.
Need money to pay for college?
Every semester, Fastweb helps thousands of students pay for school by matching them to scholarships, grants and awards for which they actually qualify. Sign up today to get started. You'll find scholarships like the Course Hero's $5,000 Scholarship, and easy to enter scholarships like Niche $1,000 Scholarship.