Print

Colleges >> Browse Articles >> Grad Schools

+2

Grad School or the Real World?

Grad School or the Real World?

By Peter Vogt, MonsterTRAK Career Coach

September 03, 2008

After finishing her journalism undergraduate degree in 2004, 24-year-old Laurie Duffy went straight to graduate school. On the other hand, 33-year-old Carolyn Kaufman worked in information technology for two years after completing her undergraduate degree and then went to grad school. Who made the better decision?

It’s impossible to be certain. Both Duffy, with a master’s degree in corporate communication, and Kaufman, who earned her doctorate in clinical psychology, have landed on their feet from a career perspective: Duffy works in public relations; Kaufman teaches psychology.

Welcome to the haziness surrounding a question many college seniors wrestle with: Should I go to graduate school right after I complete my undergraduate degree, or should I work for awhile first and then go?

While there are no easy answers, there are definitely strong opinions on both sides.

Option 1: Grad School First, Work Later

“Graduate school is difficult and very much not the traditional college experience,” says Duffy, an assistant account executive for the Winston-Salem, North Carolina, office of PR firm Mullen. The workload alone leaves little time for relationships or a career, she says. “So I chose to get my master’s right away, before I had a job I loved and couldn’t leave, or before I had a family to take care of.”

Duffy’s experience illustrates one of the most common arguments for pursuing graduate school sooner versus later. Other commitments can get into the way of furthering your education. And particularly once you start a family, it can be difficult to fit grad school into your life, says Nancy Stamp, dean of the graduate school at Binghamton University.

Other potential advantages of going to graduate school right away include the freedom to relocate in order to pursue the program you really want. It’s also been said that going right to graduate school allows you to simply continue in the school mode you’ve been in for the last 16 years instead of having to kick-start your academic side later.

Option 2: Work First, Grad School Later

But career expert Anna Ivey, author of The Ivey Guide to Law School Admissions, doesn’t buy this argument. “Plenty of people go off and work before grad school, and they do wonderfully back in the classroom,” she says. “Bringing real-world experience to the classroom only makes them better grad students.”

That’s exactly what Kaufman experienced. She says she intended to go to graduate school immediately after finishing her undergraduate degree in English and psychology in 1995 but put it off, because she couldn’t decide where to go.

“That was the best thing that could have happened,” says Kaufman, who teaches psychology full-time at Columbus State Community College and part-time at Otterbein College. “Developing my confidence and sense of competence, learning new skills and contemplating whether I really wanted to go back or continue what I was doing…was priceless and has helped me make better decisions after graduate school.”

Other people discover the right path for them by hindsight. For example, 34-year-old Melanie Szlucha participated in a special academic program that allowed her to complete both a bachelor’s degree in management and an MBA in just five years — by the time she was only 24.

Today, after 10 years of hiring experience, she says she probably wouldn’t make the same decision again. “I liken it to giving a 12-year-old a driver’s license,” says Szlucha, president of Red Inc., an interview and presentation coaching firm. “They can learn the mechanics of how to drive the car, but nobody is going to give them the keys to the car.”

Thus, there’s no point in getting married to graduate school right out of college, says Ivey. “Grad school isn’t going anywhere,” she stresses. “Take some time to figure out who you are outside of school.”


+2
  • Photo_user_blank_big

    jjrolfe

    8 months ago

    You know one thing that is hard to debate about this dilemma is that everyone's financial, socioeconomic, and maturity are all important factors when making this decision. I know a handful of close friends who claimed that they will never go back to school after they finished their undergrad. However, in the last two years all of them have either not found a job or found a job where that they hate because they cannot move up. However, I understand that not everyone can afford to go to grad school whether it be money, demands of the job, or have the responsibilities of taking care of a family. That's why I think the best way to go about this is asking what you really want. I would've loved to go to a traditional grad school like Stanford, UCLA, Oregon, USC. etc. However, I live in the south and I have a job that doesn't really allow much free time outside of work so I'm doing my Masters of Business Administration at a school that offers an online format (http://www.floridatechonline.com/graduate-masters-degree-healthcare-management.asp). I may have had to make the sacrifice, but this way I'm able to keep my job, pay my bills, and have the convenience of going straight home to work on my classes as oppose to having to travel to a campus during rush hour after work. That is my situation though. My advice to anyone in a similar situation is that if you can afford to do it go there as quickly as possible.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    carla1204

    over 1 year ago

    Need this for my paper

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    json

    over 1 year ago

    There are proponents of both schools of thought. Some say it’s best to go to graduate school right after college as you’ve the momentum to study. Some also argue that once you’ve experienced the professional world, it can get difficult to adjust back to a classroom schedule. There are others, however, who recommend getting some real world experience under your belt before you go back to grad school. According to them, graduates will be able to maximize their learning experience if they bring some professional training to the table. Besides, real world experience will provide the kind of discipline and commitment that graduate degrees require. You’ll also get some time to think if you want to build on your existing skills or learn some new ones and choose a program accordingly.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    OuedraogoO2

    about 2 years ago

    dear;i am hubert ouedraogo from burkina faso;i enrolled in my second years of universite of koudougou,and i want to benefit a aid in order to purchase my grad study.THANK

  • Horse-beach_max50

    LisaV83

    over 2 years ago

    in hindsight, I wish I had gone right out of college... i was 48 and a single mother of 4 when i decided to return for my graduate degree. teenagers and life in general make it very difficult to keep up with the newly graduated. the upside is that now i have the confidence in what i really want to do to go after the degree that i wish i would have did my undergrad program in. the vote is still up in the air i guess! haha i always felt the call to ministry even as a young girl, but didn't have the mentorship or coaching to help me make the right decisions then. i unfortunately made the decision to go with the logical choice that would provide a living for myself... well that has not proven to be the best choice after all. i've learned thru life experiences that when you are called to do something for the Lord Jesus, you will not be happy or fulfilled in life until you DO IT. i love my kids and i wouldn't trade them, but it really gets old working to make a living when you do not have a "life" that you enjoy in the process. i trust now that i am pursuing that lifelong calling that God will work it all together for my good and His glory... i just can't help but regret a lot of wasted years that i could have been making a difference in other people's lives. i am glad that with God it's never too late to start, and He knows how to make up for the "lost time". I would advise young people to seek out people who DO what they think they'd like to do, and hang out with them and get some practical advice before jumping into something because their friends or parents are pushing them to make some decisions. take advantage of the experience and wisdom of those who have gone before you. why make your life harder than it has to be? :) God bless you as you make your choices.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    KarenK43

    over 2 years ago

    Another thing that wasn't mentioned is a student's career choice or desires. I went to grad school right after college to get my PhD so that I could become a college professor, something that is highly improbable without that degree. There have been some students in my program who have felt that one needs to spend some time at least teaching before going to grad school (to make sure that's really what one wants to do); they have generally been surprised to find out that it is not an option for everybody. For a large portion of my childhood, I wanted to be a teacher, but in order to become a teacher in my geographical area, one needs at least a masters degree. I simply figured that if I was going to have to get a masters to teach anyway, I might as well go for the PhD, since what I really wanted to do was teach at the college level.
    As for the cost, (at least in my field) there is very little funding available for masters programs, but PhD programs are much better about that. My college professors told me not to go to grad school unless I was paid to do so--funding is absolutely necessary.
    Darksunshine and NaudiaJ were right--some people already know what they want and some people need to make sure. Neither group is better or worse than the other.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    NaudiaJ

    over 2 years ago

    I agree with Jennifer, the cost is astounding, plus it's a lot easier to get scholarships as an undergraduate so money is a huge factor in deciding to go to grad school...I also agree with Darksunshine...it is up to the individual, some people know exactly what they want to do and should go straight for it while others just need to get a little experience and then get back on the band wagon knowing exactly what they want to attain :)

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    ZewduA2

    over 2 years ago

    really ,i appriciate the expirences of the university in helping students learn and change thier career and life. i want to be one of the students' of this university
    thanks!!

  • Books_max50

    FaisalAliS

    over 2 years ago

    It's simply great.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    Darksunshine

    over 2 years ago

    Life is about choices and the path that got you to college in the first place. We all have external and internal pressures on which road to choose. There isn't a right answer or wrong answer, it really depends on each individual situation.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    JenniferA1208

    over 2 years ago

    Employers who pay for masters and doctorate degrees were not mentioned in this article. Cost was not mentioned as a factor at all. The ability to pay for school is a huge deciding factor.

  • Photo_user_blank_big

    JeanPaulN8

    over 2 years ago

    Dear, i am NDAYISHIMIYE jean paul from RWANDA i achieved third year in Law faculty so i want to benefit that scholarship that you offering in Master of Business Administration[MBA].